With Diamond Tables you receive 25% off the check at

Croton Reservoir Tavern

American Pub Fare$21 - $30
108 W. 40th Street, New York City, NY 10018

Restaurant Information

About Croton Reservoir Tavern
Croton Reservoir Tavern serves savory and creative American Pub Fare and comfort food in a cozy atmosphere. This neighborhood gathering place is also popular for cocktails, beers and has a few TVs to watch your favorite sporting events. We’re open for lunch, dinner, brunch and late night

Cuisine
We offer steak, seafood, pasta, salads, small plates, desserts and much more. Also a popular brunch spot with a “Bottomless Brunch” option. Menu items include CRT DELUXE BURGER featuring Certified Angus Beef, applewood smoked bacon, smoked gouda, caramelized onions, avocado, lettuce, tomato, chipotle aioli, brioche bun, house fries for $21, HANGER STEAK that is pan seared with sautéed spinach, horseradish mashed potatoes, peppercorn jus for $29, and a GRILLED PORK CHOP featuring Heritage Farms cider-brined 10oz. pork chop, roasted Brussels sprouts, polenta, green apple, cider gastrique for $29.

Location
Conveniently located halfway between Times Square and Bryan Park, in the lower part of the center of Midtown Manhattan.

Diamond Tables

Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
4:00 pm   Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table
4:15 pm   Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table
4:30 pm   Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table
4:45 pm   Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table
5:00 pm   Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table
5:15 pm   Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table
5:30 pm   Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table
5:45 pm   Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table
6:00 pm   Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table
6:15 pm   Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table
6:30 pm   Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table
6:45 pm   Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table
7:00 pm   Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table
7:15 pm   Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table
7:30 pm   Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table
7:45 pm   Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table
8:00 pm   Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table
8:15 pm   Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table
8:30 pm   Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table
8:45 pm   Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table
9:00 pm   Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table
9:15 pm   Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table
9:30 pm   Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table
9:45 pm   Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table
10:00 pm   Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table

Reviews

Overall Rating

3.8
Rating results
Rating scope
24 reviews
  • 5 Stars
  • 4 Stars
  • 3 Stars
  • 2 Stars
  • 1 Star
Placeholder image
A Zwolensky
Rating results
Rating scope
2016-07-07
Happened upon this place. Great burger and eclectic menu choices. Good prices as well. Small place, not a lot of seating but worth a short wait.
Placeholder image
Igor Ganapolsky
Rating results
Rating scope
2016-06-11
The food is good quality here, especially the shrimps. The atmosphere is laid back and calm too. However, this place is ridiculously overpriced. They mandate a twenty percent gratuity on your bill, so you'll end up paying an arm and a leg no matter what you order. Suggestion to the manager: it is unheard of to mandate such a high gratuity at other restaurants in NYC!
Placeholder image
Sophia Boudinova
Rating results
Rating scope
2016-07-17
We have celebrated here few times. Very good service, food is great. Downstairs is great for group meetings and celebrations.
Placeholder image
Adam Ahl
Rating results
Rating scope
2016-07-19
I have only been here once, but the staff seemed friendly, the prices were reasonable and the drinks were strong. I'll be back soon.
Placeholder image
Ginger B
Rating results
Rating scope
2015-12-17
I've been here for different events and like the basement bar space. Last night came for dinner at the restaurant for the first time. The bar area upstairs gets crowded so people were overflowing into the area where we were dining and the noise level was really high. Sometimes the three of us had difficulty hearing each other. The food was very good but pricey. I would be back to try the food at the downstairs bar but not at the upstairs restaurant again.
Placeholder image
Chris Albanese
Rating results
Rating scope
2016-09-09
Good standard Irish pub. The burger is excellent as is the buffalo chicken wrap. Pretty good beer menu too, but I wouldn't consider this a "craft beer" spot by any means. Service is fast an attentive. I really like this spot for a quick work lunch.
Placeholder image
Agatha Mallet
Rating results
Rating scope
2016-10-21
Amazing, fun place for happy hour! And it goes till 10 pm!! Great deal for midtown!
Placeholder image
Sarah Ryck
Rating results
Rating scope
2016-11-29
We (4 adults 2 older kids) stopped in for some drinks and apps and were literally the only people in the place. Drinks were good, but the waitress had no idea about the selection they offered, which resulted in the wrong drink a few too many times. Not to mention it took half an hour to get the drinks. One member of our party ordered soup and bread but didn't get the bread until he was finished with the soup.
Placeholder image
mvlandi
Rating results
Rating scope
2016-12-27
Awesome restaurant. Great service, amazing food and the prices are great compared to other upper scale restaurants. Lunch is booming and dinner is intimate. I'm a regular now.
Placeholder image
Doug White
Rating results
Rating scope
2016-07-29
Good is very good for lunches. Nice atmosphere
Placeholder image
Matthew Mason
Rating results
Rating scope
2016-07-26
Skirt steak sandwich was awesome. Great place all around
Placeholder image
Viktoria Gorzo von Bilkei
Rating results
Rating scope
2017-01-19
Fantastic, friendly service. Good prices. Polenta fries to die for.
Placeholder image
Michael
Rating results
Rating scope
2016-12-27
Awesome restaurant. Great service, amazing food and the prices are great compared to other upper scale restaurants. Lunch is booming and dinner is intimate. I'm a regular now.
Placeholder image
Sandy T
Rating results
Rating scope
2017-02-17
Okay for after work drinks if you're in the area. Happy hour drinks from 5-10pm so that's good too but selection is limited
Placeholder image
Chris Childs
Rating results
Rating scope
2017-03-20
Great place to grab a drink after work. Food is good but a bit pricey.
Placeholder image
Forrest Hayes
Rating results
Rating scope
2017-05-27
Very good business lunch and more room downstairs. Food is consistently good. Solid happy hour but it does get crowded. But that's kind of the point as who wants to drink alone?!
Placeholder image
Matthew Lecours
Rating results
Rating scope
2017-06-14
great food - a classier than usual option for after work drinks or food without going over the top
Placeholder image
Anthony Francis
Rating results
Rating scope
2017-06-29
Is my friend's birthday we arrive late and got amazing treatment of service quick and drinks came on time and made correctly which in the city you cannot always get every time the manager Sean was fantastic and made sure we had everything we needed and kept checking on us periodically would recommend this place to any person that's visiting New York
Placeholder image
Kiersten Gourlay
Rating results
Rating scope
2017-11-01
Decent price, soggy fries unfortunately. The burger was decent as well.
Placeholder image
Alexei Kossov
Rating results
Rating scope
2017-11-22
Good food. Good place for company of friends.
Placeholder image
Matthew Diener
Rating results
Rating scope
2017-11-29
Great food, great service, great atmosphere. If you want a good, affordable lunch or dinner in Midtown, stop here.
Placeholder image
Iron Zhopa
Rating results
Rating scope
2017-12-02
I love their happy hour although sometimes it's hard to get a service
Placeholder image
Gelo Petsvona
Rating results
Rating scope
2017-12-05
Good food of you up for a simple meal, fast service at lunch. A little pricey.
Placeholder image
Nihal Patel
Rating results
Rating scope
2017-12-06
Happy hour is good so it gets the job done. But a bit overpriced otherwise.
Load more reviews Show More
Show less reviews Show Less
Thank you Danijel Grabež. You are successfully signed up to Diamond Tables.
Close notification