With Diamond Tables you receive 25% off the check at

Croton Reservoir Tavern

American Pub Fare$21 - $30
108 W. 40th Street, New York City, NY 10018

Restaurant Information

About Croton Reservoir Tavern
Croton Reservoir Tavern serves savory and creative American Pub Fare and comfort food in a cozy atmosphere. This neighborhood gathering place is also popular for cocktails, beers and has a few TVs to watch your favorite sporting events. We’re open for lunch, dinner, brunch and late night

Cuisine
We offer steak, seafood, pasta, salads, small plates, desserts and much more. Also a popular brunch spot with a “Bottomless Brunch” option. Menu items include CRT DELUXE BURGER featuring Certified Angus Beef, applewood smoked bacon, smoked gouda, caramelized onions, avocado, lettuce, tomato, chipotle aioli, brioche bun, house fries for $21, HANGER STEAK that is pan seared with sautéed spinach, horseradish mashed potatoes, peppercorn jus for $29, and a GRILLED PORK CHOP featuring Heritage Farms cider-brined 10oz. pork chop, roasted Brussels sprouts, polenta, green apple, cider gastrique for $29.

Location
Conveniently located halfway between Times Square and Bryan Park, in the lower part of the center of Midtown Manhattan.

Diamond Tables

Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
4:00 pm   Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table
4:15 pm   Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table
4:30 pm   Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table
4:45 pm   Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table
5:00 pm   Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table
5:15 pm   Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table
5:30 pm   Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table
5:45 pm   Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table
6:00 pm   Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table
6:15 pm   Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table
6:30 pm   Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table
6:45 pm   Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table
7:00 pm   Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table
7:15 pm   Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table
7:30 pm   Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table
7:45 pm   Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table
8:00 pm   Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table
8:15 pm   Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table
8:30 pm   Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table
8:45 pm   Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table
9:00 pm   Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table
9:15 pm   Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table
9:30 pm   Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table
9:45 pm   Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table
10:00 pm   Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table

Reviews

Overall Rating

4.2
Rating results
Rating scope
108 reviews
  • 5 Stars
  • 4 Stars
  • 3 Stars
  • 2 Stars
  • 1 Star
Placeholder image
A Zwolensky
Rating results
Rating scope
2016-07-07
Happened upon this place. Great burger and eclectic menu choices. Good prices as well. Small place, not a lot of seating but worth a short wait.
Placeholder image
Igor Ganapolsky
Rating results
Rating scope
2016-06-11
The food is good quality here, especially the shrimps. The atmosphere is laid back and calm too. However, this place is ridiculously overpriced. They mandate a twenty percent gratuity on your bill, so you'll end up paying an arm and a leg no matter what you order. Suggestion to the manager: it is unheard of to mandate such a high gratuity at other restaurants in NYC!
Placeholder image
Sophia Boudinova
Rating results
Rating scope
2016-07-17
We have celebrated here few times. Very good service, food is great. Downstairs is great for group meetings and celebrations.
Placeholder image
Adam Ahl
Rating results
Rating scope
2016-07-19
I have only been here once, but the staff seemed friendly, the prices were reasonable and the drinks were strong. I'll be back soon.
Placeholder image
Ginger B
Rating results
Rating scope
2015-12-17
I've been here for different events and like the basement bar space. Last night came for dinner at the restaurant for the first time. The bar area upstairs gets crowded so people were overflowing into the area where we were dining and the noise level was really high. Sometimes the three of us had difficulty hearing each other. The food was very good but pricey. I would be back to try the food at the downstairs bar but not at the upstairs restaurant again.
Placeholder image
Chris Albanese
Rating results
Rating scope
2016-09-09
Good standard Irish pub. The burger is excellent as is the buffalo chicken wrap. Pretty good beer menu too, but I wouldn't consider this a "craft beer" spot by any means. Service is fast an attentive. I really like this spot for a quick work lunch.
Placeholder image
Agatha Mallet
Rating results
Rating scope
2016-10-21
Amazing, fun place for happy hour! And it goes till 10 pm!! Great deal for midtown!
Placeholder image
Sarah Ryck
Rating results
Rating scope
2016-11-29
We (4 adults 2 older kids) stopped in for some drinks and apps and were literally the only people in the place. Drinks were good, but the waitress had no idea about the selection they offered, which resulted in the wrong drink a few too many times. Not to mention it took half an hour to get the drinks. One member of our party ordered soup and bread but didn't get the bread until he was finished with the soup.
Placeholder image
mvlandi
Rating results
Rating scope
2016-12-27
Awesome restaurant. Great service, amazing food and the prices are great compared to other upper scale restaurants. Lunch is booming and dinner is intimate. I'm a regular now.
Placeholder image
Doug White
Rating results
Rating scope
2016-07-29
Good is very good for lunches. Nice atmosphere
Placeholder image
Matthew Mason
Rating results
Rating scope
2016-07-26
Skirt steak sandwich was awesome. Great place all around
Placeholder image
Viktoria Gorzo von Bilkei
Rating results
Rating scope
2017-01-19
Fantastic, friendly service. Good prices. Polenta fries to die for.
Placeholder image
Michael
Rating results
Rating scope
2016-12-27
Awesome restaurant. Great service, amazing food and the prices are great compared to other upper scale restaurants. Lunch is booming and dinner is intimate. I'm a regular now.
Placeholder image
Sandy T
Rating results
Rating scope
2017-02-17
Okay for after work drinks if you're in the area. Happy hour drinks from 5-10pm so that's good too but selection is limited
Placeholder image
Chris Childs
Rating results
Rating scope
2017-03-20
Great place to grab a drink after work. Food is good but a bit pricey.
Placeholder image
Forrest Hayes
Rating results
Rating scope
2017-05-27
Very good business lunch and more room downstairs. Food is consistently good. Solid happy hour but it does get crowded. But that's kind of the point as who wants to drink alone?!
Placeholder image
Matthew Lecours
Rating results
Rating scope
2017-06-14
great food - a classier than usual option for after work drinks or food without going over the top
Placeholder image
Anthony Francis
Rating results
Rating scope
2017-06-29
Is my friend's birthday we arrive late and got amazing treatment of service quick and drinks came on time and made correctly which in the city you cannot always get every time the manager Sean was fantastic and made sure we had everything we needed and kept checking on us periodically would recommend this place to any person that's visiting New York
Placeholder image
Kiersten Gourlay
Rating results
Rating scope
2017-11-01
Decent price, soggy fries unfortunately. The burger was decent as well.
Placeholder image
Alexei Kossov
Rating results
Rating scope
2017-11-22
Good food. Good place for company of friends.
Placeholder image
Matthew Diener
Rating results
Rating scope
2017-11-29
Great food, great service, great atmosphere. If you want a good, affordable lunch or dinner in Midtown, stop here.
Placeholder image
Iron Zhopa
Rating results
Rating scope
2017-12-02
I love their happy hour although sometimes it's hard to get a service
Placeholder image
Gelo Petsvona
Rating results
Rating scope
2017-12-05
Good food of you up for a simple meal, fast service at lunch. A little pricey.
Placeholder image
Nihal Patel
Rating results
Rating scope
2017-12-06
Happy hour is good so it gets the job done. But a bit overpriced otherwise.
Placeholder image
Christopher Adams
Rating results
Rating scope
2017-12-13
Reasonably priced, warmly lit spot with good food and drink options and located very close to Bryant Park.
Placeholder image
Jeremy G
Rating results
Rating scope
2017-12-23
Great thanksgiving day dinner. Staff was awesome and the food amazing
Placeholder image
Michael Wakeman
Rating results
Rating scope
2017-12-23
Place is ok. Usually overcrowded. Food is ok, service is ok. Nothing too special.
Placeholder image
Edgardo Forti
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-01-09
I come here for drinks, service and atmosphere is great.
Placeholder image
Kiranteja chadalawada
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-01-22
The Quinoa Avocado Salad was amazing. Never have I ever felt ad that I was finishing my salad. It was so good. Great Cocktails too!
Placeholder image
M-P Amendolare
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-01-27
Nice quiet spot for drinks, music isn’t too loud so you can have a conversation with friends.
Placeholder image
Charlie Garland
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-02-08
Great after work gathering place. Excellent lunch specials too.
Placeholder image
Allen Keeler
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-02-16
Quiet place for dinner. Very good food. Excellent service
Placeholder image
Asad Ali
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-04-01
Good ambience and decor, but food was not great
Placeholder image
Andrew Flynn
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-04-10
Great local bar. Friendly bartenders and good food. One of the best burgers in town!!
Placeholder image
Dennis L. Stephens
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-05-06
Nice ambience and good food. And the interesting cocktail list makes the place a good dining experience.
Placeholder image
jummy akintomide
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-05-01
Gets so crowded after work. If you come in ard 7 its not so bad. Good happy and bartender but once you add food the bill can stack up.
Placeholder image
Amos Elroy
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-05-14
I hate to advertise a meat eating establishment, as I personally believe in resorting to meet eating minimally due to humane reasons (mostly during travel), but if you are going to have meet, this is the place to go for sure! No question about it. Best cavapi and cavapcici in town according to multiple locals.
Placeholder image
David Hartman
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-05-11
Fell upon this place. Really great atmosphere, great burger, and overall a great experience.
Placeholder image
Janet Jimenez
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-05-18
This is our company "go to" place for after work get-togethers. Good Atmosphere, drinks, food and service.
Placeholder image
T NYPRD
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-06-09
Went to happy hour with friends after work. Food and service were poor. Ordered nachos, but no flavor and needed a fork, which took nearly an hour and a half to get after asking 4 times.
Placeholder image
Seth Stevens
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-06-21
We had lunch here. Good food, everyone was friendly and I would return if I were in the area.
Placeholder image
sumalena thakore
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-06-28
Great place for a quick lunch meeting or also for a small company party. They have good fingure food selection. I have been to one of my past company party there and it was very nice
Placeholder image
Josephine Guttadauro
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-07-04
Great Mid town Tavern vibe Good food and service NY business locals close to Bryant Park
Placeholder image
Nelson L Urgiles
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-07-19
I always feel welcomed at this bar. Great ambiance.
Placeholder image
Anuj Nagpal
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-07-31
Great food, drinks and ambience. Spinach and Corn Artichoke was awesome
Placeholder image
Lyn F
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-07-29
Nice place in midtown they have nice drinks and service is usually excellent.
Placeholder image
J Mac
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-08-08
Went for a co-worker's birthday party. She rented the lower level. Nice space, good food and just big enough for a small gathering up to like 30 people or so.
Placeholder image
sj herath
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-08-13
Usually crouded on weekdays and weekends after 4pm. They have small snack menu, such as sliders,nachos, burgers,pizza, etc. to order food or drink you have to go to the bar counter and its takes time. And its too loud there usually pack with poeple. Some time cant get a space to reach without disturbing some ones conversation. They have some space in downstairs too anyway its overall nice place to hangout.
Placeholder image
muse joseph
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-08-16
Nice, easy going, laid back vibe. well prepared drinks. obviously geared toward an older crowd. music wasn't so loud to be obnoxious, but also never went later than the 60s. mostly early Motown and other pop tunes of that era. it was early afternoon, so maybe their catalog time travels @ sundown. Their frozen sangria hit the spot. didn't really enjoy their Passion Pit cocktail. Great treating bar bites. pretty nice after work spot.
Placeholder image
Steve Kupitz
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-09-10
My wife and I stopped in since we had an hour to kill before our flight back home to Chicago and we had a great time. Granted we weren’t here for very long nor did we have anything off of their food menu but here were the positives: the staff was friendly, professional and attentive, the restaurant and bar area were clean and the atmosphere was great. I loved the dark wood and the huge selection of whiskey. If we’re ever in New York City again, we’d gladly stop here again.
Placeholder image
shorabji ssp
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-09-05
Nice cozy bar to hang out after stressful 8 hours at work. Happy hour, cheap drinks and the best is their burgers and soft pretzels. a perfect place for everyday relaxation to your brain. Friendly bartenders.
Placeholder image
robert johnson
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-10-15
Small Tavern upstairs. But, the lower level offers additional space for mingling. The food is delicious (try the CRT Nachos) and comes out quickly.
Placeholder image
Jon McCarthy
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-11-03
Great place for lunch, there’s a deal at the bar where you get a sandwich, burger, or salad along with a beer or a glass of wine for $20. Food is tasty and well made. Bar staff is very friendly and attentive. Recommended!
Placeholder image
Jon McCarthy
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-11-02
Good lunch special at the bar, sandwich or a burger and a beer for $20. Food is tasty and well made. Bar staff is very friendly and attentive. Recommended!
Placeholder image
Kendall Moses
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-11-11
I was simply passed thru the Croton Reservoir Tavern to get to a Quiet event in their basement. But in passing thru I did notice that the place was very nice, the lights were very dim giving the place a cozy vibe.
Placeholder image
Adrien Patané
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-11-19
Cozy little pub with decent selection of booze, great place to relax after wandering around Bryant Park!
Placeholder image
Bea Zio
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-12-10
Large selection of spirits on the back shelf, some interesting drinks to choose from the menu which I think rotates seasonally? High clean bar, airy space and efficient bar personnel though it was quite busy. Prices bit less than average NY though the place is nice and looks elegant
Placeholder image
Tom Gladd
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-12-08
Comfortable atmosphere, good prices, great service. We can't wait to go again.
Placeholder image
Dave Hobbs
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-12-16
Went here to the downstairs room for a corporate event. Service was great. Food was good (buffet line). Music was a little loud for easy conversations you generally get for business stuff. But the DJ was good. I'd go back for sure.
Placeholder image
Rhiannon Galen
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-12-29
My family had a great experience here! It's always hard to find a good place in the city and not have to wait forever. We have 2 small kids who also had a good time!!!
Placeholder image
Tori Golden
Rating results
Rating scope
2019-02-17
Best decision made coming here. We walked all around time square but it was too touristy so not too far away near Bryant Park we found this restaurant and the food was incredible! the restaurant has a nice bar but a classy vibe and low lighting. Not crowded and very comfortable. Food was so damn good. Service was great too.
Placeholder image
Roman Sir
Rating results
Rating scope
2019-02-20
You can say an iconic place in the mid-town New York City. Proven delicious menu and always a great option for after work drinks with coworkers.
Placeholder image
Joshua Barbee
Rating results
Rating scope
2019-02-28
We had a delicious business lunch at Croton Reservoir Tavern. The service was friendly, professional and attentive. The food was prepared well, fresh and excellent. We will definitely be recommending and visiting again.
Placeholder image
damaris adamo
Rating results
Rating scope
2019-03-20
what a delightful bartender we had very willing to open up a new bottle of Bordeaux just for us as well as suggest one of the many bourbon scotch and whiskey they have available a great late night nightcap
Placeholder image
Holly Trantham
Rating results
Rating scope
2019-04-12
Very bro-y and crowded on work nights but decent happy hour specials
Placeholder image
brian g
Rating results
Rating scope
2019-05-04
Excellent burger, good cocktails. Good place to grab a quick bite.
Placeholder image
Willow Ramos
Rating results
Rating scope
2019-05-10
cool location to meet with coworkers. the staff was helpful and kind. it has a cool feel to it.
Placeholder image
Stephen Pile
Rating results
Rating scope
2019-05-17
The fries Lovely place. Great vibe and inviting atmosphere. My server for the day, Justin was very helpful!!... Top man! The fries were well done. I will definitely come back.
Placeholder image
Phil Serafino
Rating results
Rating scope
2019-05-30
Great beer list and the appetizers were quite tasty; especially liked the artichoke dip. (Didn't try any of the main courses). Nice atmosphere. Yasmin the hostess and Tanya, our waitress, took good care of us. Highly recommended.
Placeholder image
Jim & Inna
Rating results
Rating scope
2019-07-12
Nice place in the craziness of Bryant park! Service here was good. Beer line can use some checking as we had a couple flat lagers in our group...but all in all good place to visit if you’re in the area
Placeholder image
Irene V
Rating results
Rating scope
2019-08-16
Good lunch at the bar but tough to get a bartender's attention after work. Average drink selection - challenging if you'd like a good glass of wine.
Placeholder image
Irene Vagianos
Rating results
Rating scope
2019-08-16
Good lunch at the bar but tough to get a bartender's attention after work. Average drink selection - challenging if you'd like a good glass of wine.
Placeholder image
Tyler Gitter
Rating results
Rating scope
2019-09-11
Wow, fantastic. Great selection of beers and scotch. Food is great. Service was great. A+
Placeholder image
Maceo Brown
Rating results
Rating scope
2019-09-20
Good, upscale pub atmosphere. The waitress and other staff were quite pleasant. Nice vibe for an after work drink or quick dinner.
Placeholder image
Brian Maysa
Rating results
Rating scope
2019-09-20
Great after work drink specials. Highly recommend the downstairs bar.
Placeholder image
Eric Garcia
Rating results
Rating scope
2019-10-24
I like this place but it’s a bit expensive for lunch and or dinner but then again it’s just outside Times Square. I usually arrange meet and greets and or first dates since the decor is nice and the menu offers many types of choices. It’s also near my office which helps too.
Placeholder image
jose miguel isaza herrera
Rating results
Rating scope
2019-11-10
Had a great time on a Saturday night with my two special ladies. Great vibe and a great service as well.
Placeholder image
Paul Swithers
Rating results
Rating scope
2019-11-23
We went here for drinks after a work event and shared a few standard bar appetizers. Everything was good. The ambience, the service, the clientele, the food. For a very touristy neighborhood, this had a good enough city vibe that I would go back if I were nearby again.
Placeholder image
Willem Koenders
Rating results
Rating scope
2019-11-24
Came here with a client to have a few drinks at the bar. Always plenty of folks. Good that the music isn’t too loud.
Placeholder image
Marcia Corcella
Rating results
Rating scope
2019-12-04
Food!!! I've tried a little bit of everything from the Croton kitchen but I love their Mac & Cheese! It is super filling and i always ask to add chicken and bacon to top it off. Their nachos, hummus, & sweet potato fries all pass as a good bar snack.
Placeholder image
Mike Riva
Rating results
Rating scope
2019-12-11
Food was delicous & reasonably priced. Nice atmosphere, attentive friendly staff. Good drinks. We will definitely dine there again. Unfortunately, I forgot to take pix of food - beautifully plated.
Placeholder image
Diane Ventura
Rating results
Rating scope
2019-12-16
Great ambiance for a tavern and burger was delicious. I liked the menu and the variety it offered. I definitely would go back.
Placeholder image
Danny Rowland
Rating results
Rating scope
2019-12-23
It is a nice place. They keep dim lighting inside which makes for a decent atmosphere. They play music, but not too loud. There is a downstairs area and bar that is nice and a little more cozy. In the winter they have coat racks out for you to hang your things up if you would like, but they didn't force us to. The bathrooms were clean, the drinks were reasonable, the service was quick and friendly.
Placeholder image
Alok Agrawal
Rating results
Rating scope
2019-12-28
Good burgers. Good for afternoon meeting and lunches. I got veggie options as well
Placeholder image
Donna Lehigh
Rating results
Rating scope
2020-01-02
Love this restaurant! Great food! Easy walk from Radio City Music Hall.
Placeholder image
BobbiJo Girroir
Rating results
Rating scope
2020-01-08
Was great, we needed to catch our tour bus.acroos the way at the park so I wanted to book a close restaurant. The reservation app was easy & I am glad I used it. There were about 5 groups who walked in approx the same time, I told the greeter my name and we were sat right away. Excellent food options and the waitstaff were wonderful, it had been a long day touring the city and I just wanted a steady flow of 3 cocktails and they catered to that want, also catered to my daughters dietary wants in the food prep. Would go.again next time we are touring the city.
Placeholder image
Keven Melara
Rating results
Rating scope
2020-02-01
I’ve been coming here for 3 years since working in Midtown. Nice bartenders and great service .. very friendly. Happy hour is poppin n prices are good. Note: only downstairs is happy hour but it’s an awesome vibe.
Placeholder image
Benjamin Costabile
Rating results
Rating scope
2020-02-01
This is my favorite local bar. If it’s for a sit down dinner, or a drink downstairs during happy hour, service is always on point and the staff is super friendly. The bartenders always hook you up too, super dope.
Placeholder image
Alex Levine
Rating results
Rating scope
2020-02-19
Didnt have any food so the hostess very nicely rearranged existing patrons so me and my guest could sit together at the bar. The drink selection is amazing if you are into scotch and DECENT if into bourbon and very limited rye. My only comment would be for the bar to expand their bourbon and rye offerings. But all in all a very positive experience
Placeholder image
Suzette Azariah Gunn
Rating results
Rating scope
2020-02-25
Chill vibe, great happy hour drinks and prices. Cool wait staff, good eats. A nice low key place to chill without having to be fancy. Good for friends and date.
Placeholder image
Marc Ras
Rating results
Rating scope
2020-02-25
I love this place. Been here two times and both times great friendly service. The food is great and also has a good bar crowd that is not onto of you while dining. My new go to place
Placeholder image
Executive Thrillseeker
Rating results
Rating scope
2019-07-12
Nice place in the craziness of Bryant park! Service here was good. Beer line can use some checking as we had a couple flat lagers in our group...but all in all good place to visit if you’re in the area
Placeholder image
Jason Ansible
Rating results
Rating scope
2020-07-22
Nice service and good drinks, relative for what it is. Also they require a mask if you walk inside to use the bathroom, which is a good sign.
Placeholder image
Jason Virga
Rating results
Rating scope
2020-07-22
Nice service and good drinks, relative for what it is. Also they require a mask if you walk inside to use the bathroom, which is a good sign.
Placeholder image
Eric Garcia
Rating results
Rating scope
2019-12-05
I like this place but it’s a bit expensive for lunch and or dinner but then again it’s just outside Times Square. I usually arrange meet and greets and or first dates since the decor is nice and the menu offers many types of choices. It’s also near my office which helps too.
Placeholder image
Suzette Azariah “Rebel Fleur” Gunn
Rating results
Rating scope
2020-02-25
Chill vibe, great happy hour drinks and prices. Cool wait staff, good eats. A nice low key place to chill without having to be fancy. Good for friends and date.
Placeholder image
Jason Bingle
Rating results
Rating scope
2020-07-22
Nice service and good drinks, relative for what it is. Also they require a mask if you walk inside to use the bathroom, which is a good sign.
Placeholder image
dana nunez
Rating results
Rating scope
2020-11-04
It's so appetizing. This place has a great feel to it.
Placeholder image
Christopher Ramnarine
Rating results
Rating scope
2020-12-01
This is a great spot just a few steps away from Bryant Park. The staff are impeccable, very polite, very attentive and happy to assist you with your orders. I really like both the server and bartender who assisted us. There is limiting seating currently but we got a spot close to the bar, what I liked was the cocktails were affordable for the location and really really good! I had a whiskey sour that had great flavor and the Manhattan was strong! I also ordered a paloma and my server could see i didn't enjoy the drink as much as the tequila was overpowering the drink and offered to add more grapefruit juice to make it better. Its a worthwhile place to check out when you're in and around time square or Rockefeller center
Placeholder image
Dawn
Rating results
Rating scope
2020-12-07
This was a fun and very inviting bar/restaurant right off Bryant Park. Everyone was extremely friendly and welcoming and the food was wonderful. Great drinks too-I had hot cider with a shot if Fireball. Just what I needed after freezing most of the afternoon!
Placeholder image
Joe Lee
Rating results
Rating scope
2020-12-23
Awesome restaurant. Great service, amazing food and the prices are great compared to other upper scale restaurants.
Placeholder image
David Rios
Rating results
Rating scope
2021-03-03
Great food & drinks...
Placeholder image
jaclyn jaffe
Rating results
Rating scope
2021-04-01
Best Burger I have eaten and the best whiskey sour I have had in a long time. Fiance and I had dinner there last night and suffice to say we are going to be back. Even ordered delivery for tonight! Now I have to test their old fashioned. I am telling yall: go and try this place
Placeholder image
Christine Joy Magliari
Rating results
Rating scope
2021-04-20
Excellent food and drinks! The staff is superb and I highly recommend for happy hour and/or dinner any day of the week:)
Placeholder image
Roxana Guerra
Rating results
Rating scope
2021-05-10
Food is alright. Not big portions and not cheap. Happy hour drinks are a good deal though.
Placeholder image
alma campos
Rating results
Rating scope
2021-05-29
The coffee was amazing , the food was amazing , the drinks amazing! The service meh
Placeholder image
Colleen Larsen
Rating results
Rating scope
2021-06-06
Wonderful experience at Croton Reservoir Tavern!!! The manager, Keith, and our server made us feel very welcome and the food was Great! Excellent time had by all! Thanks!!
Placeholder image
Susan Berry
Rating results
Rating scope
2021-06-26
Delicious meal at a great spot. I had the Bang Bang Cauliflower as an appetizer. Great presentation and just the right amount of heat. My grilled chicken sandwich was perfect. Who doesn’t like a sandwich with bacon, avocado and Cajun ranch? The service was attentive and our food was delivered promptly. A great experience.
Load more reviews Show More
Show less reviews Show Less
Thank you Danijel Grabež. You are successfully signed up to Diamond Tables.
Close notification