With Diamond Tables you receive 25% off the check at

Shadmoor Restaurant

Seafood$21 - $30
1066 2nd Avenue, New York City, NY 10022

Restaurant Information

Shadmoor Seafood Restaurant and Cocktail Bar offers top quality seasonal seafood, fish and meat served with the best, regional produce available. With a simple yet classically modern interior the Shadmoor caters to upscale customers looking for the ambiance of Montauk beach restaurants. The menu features traditional a host of oysters, clams, and shellfish as well as Char-Grilled Branzino ($26), Royal Dorado ($26), Dover Sole ($38), and many other seafood entrees.

Diamond Tables

Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
12:00 pm Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table  
12:15 pm Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table  
12:30 pm Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table  
12:45 pm Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table  
1:00 pm Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table  
1:15 pm Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table  
1:30 pm Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table  
1:45 pm Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table  
2:00 pm Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table  
2:15 pm Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table  
2:30 pm Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table  
2:45 pm Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table  
3:00 pm Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table  
3:15 pm Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table  
3:30 pm Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table  
3:45 pm Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table  
4:00 pm Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table  
4:15 pm Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table  
4:30 pm Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table  
4:45 pm Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table  
5:00 pm Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table  
8:30 pm Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table  
8:45 pm Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table  
9:00 pm Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table  
9:15 pm Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table  
9:30 pm Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table  
9:45 pm Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table  
10:00 pm Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table  
10:15 pm Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table  
10:30 pm Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table  
10:45 pm Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table Diamond Table  

Reviews

Overall Rating

4.3
Rating results
Rating scope
111 reviews
  • 5 Stars
  • 4 Stars
  • 3 Stars
  • 2 Stars
  • 1 Star
Placeholder image
Silvana Di Giandomenico
Rating results
Rating scope
2017-06-09
We didn't have any reservations and just walked in and they were able to find us room at the bar. The bartender Luke was very attentive and the food was excellent! We had the octopus and eggpalnt as appetizers and linguine and salmon for main course. We recommend all of them especially the main courses were exceptional. The chocolate suffle was also amazing. The ambiance was very friendly. The food overall is very very good for your neighborhood restaurant.
Placeholder image
Sapna Chawla
Rating results
Rating scope
2017-05-19
I had a very nice dining experience there last night. I ordered the red snapper which was delicious! This place is now my favorite seafood restaurant in the neighborhood.
Placeholder image
Susan Zevon
Rating results
Rating scope
2017-05-30
Delicious fresh fish, vegetables and salad. Attentive staff. A very welcome addition to the neighborhood.
Placeholder image
Alex a
Rating results
Rating scope
2017-05-26
This is a new place with beautiful decor, delicious food and super cool staff. One of my favorite spots
Placeholder image
Volha Parkhats
Rating results
Rating scope
2017-05-01
The place is a work of art !!! The interior is incredible! Delicious food and drinks , reasonable prices and unique and soothing ambiance will make you come back for more.
Placeholder image
Roman Heczko
Rating results
Rating scope
2017-07-03
The home made veggie burger and the cocktails were fantastic! The staff is attentive and very professional. Great place...
Placeholder image
David Sheaffer
Rating results
Rating scope
2017-07-24
What a gem! This place has only been open for 3 months and they're firing on all cylinders. We ordered cocktails, starters and a couple main dishes. The only thing we didn't do was dessert and coffee. Everything was excellent and the wait staff was great. Highly recommended.
Placeholder image
Jody Formica
Rating results
Rating scope
2017-07-24
Didn't live up to the hype. Good food, but not amazing. It's certainly a fun bar though. Charming bartender.
Placeholder image
Ira Tau
Rating results
Rating scope
2017-07-23
This is a great spot with delicious food, fun drinks and friendly staff. We have been here a couple of times and this last time we sat at the bar and we're served by the very attentive and attractive bartender Luke. You won't be sorry.
Placeholder image
Lorraine Horwitz
Rating results
Rating scope
2017-08-22
We didn't realize the kitchen closed an hour before the actual closing time, but they served us anyways. Wonderful atmosphere and delicious drinks! Very friendly and made our visit memorable.
Placeholder image
ricky chang
Rating results
Rating scope
2017-08-29
Awesome place, great friendly vibe! Good drinks. Haven't tried the food yet. Ask for Luke!
Placeholder image
Marian Znak
Rating results
Rating scope
2017-10-14
I came to this place recently and I was very impessed. Place is charming, decorations with designer touch. Shadmoor has tasty seafood to offer. Prices are reasonable for this neighbourhood. I had grilled octopus for appetizer and branzini for main course. This is my #1 place on a list if I want to go out with my girl or bring friends who visiting me in the city. In addition amazing cocktails and excellent service. I was there on Thursday evening and had a dinner at the bar. Place was packed and I didn't have a reservation but they were so nice and let me in. Next time I will definitely make a reservation in advance.
Placeholder image
Charles Mailhot
Rating results
Rating scope
2017-10-15
Cocktails, food and service were all amazing. Really recommend the place.
Placeholder image
Brian R
Rating results
Rating scope
2017-12-05
Stopped in for a quick bite, late lunch. Beet salad with a grilled chicken breast with a glass of red wine. Very fresh, very good. Well worth the stop.
Placeholder image
lukas berlinski
Rating results
Rating scope
2017-12-16
Awesome atmosphere, amazing food and service out of this world. This is officially my new favorite place.
Placeholder image
Arthur Hurley
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-01-10
I love the decor. The food (I had the burger and calamari) was terrific. The service was great!! I will be returning.
Placeholder image
George Chao
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-01-27
Swordfish was pretty good! Wait staff was courteous and accommodating.
Placeholder image
Anthony Buffa
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-02-19
Found this gem of a place on our last night in NY. Highly recommend this place. Great food and atmosphere. Next time we are in NY we'll def be going back. Thanks Luke for a great experience.
Placeholder image
William Paul Harkins
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-02-17
Excellent food; somewhat overbearing service; price high but the food makes it worthwhile.
Placeholder image
Ahmad Namini
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-03-13
For great food and ambience, friendly staff, and above all, a wonderful time, The Shadmoor is the best. As a foodie and purveyor of liquor, I can attest that the Shadmoor spares no detail in delivering a wonderful experience. Ask for Alexandra, Jack, or Lucas. They will meet your every need. My highest and most enthusiastic endorsement. Thank you Shadmoor. I will come back again and again.
Placeholder image
[AtSign]_jeremydmiller78
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-03-14
You Just Have To _See It With Your Own Eyes_ #CocktailTheMovie
Placeholder image
Monica R
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-04-06
I love this place from the first time I've been there. Food is always fresh and stuff are very friendly. Whenever I've asked for something I've had it right away. It is great place to hang out with friends for a brunch, go for a date or celebrate holidays with family!
Placeholder image
Nicholas Luna
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-05-01
I love the u-shaped bar, which made happy hour service enjoyable to watch. The fried calamri were perfect, so we had to order two.
Placeholder image
Natan Okuniewski
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-04-25
After morning run in central park (Run as One) I went for a brunch to this place last sunday with my friends. We choose few different items (always wanna try few things in a new place) like salmon burger, eggs benedict and omelette. Salmon was delicate and tasty, eggs benedict very well made and omelette full loaded, for a dessert we took french toast full of chocolate and caramelized apples, together with coffee (which was also good) it was a nice culmination of our afternoon. Im ver happy that we found this place and probably will be back soon after our another run.
Placeholder image
Ada Ruiz
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-05-13
Very good NY steak, but for my taste I would prefer a little bit more salty/spiced. Delicious truffled fries and great place to have some wine!!
Placeholder image
Walt Kaplan
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-06-30
Great meal. High quality ingredients, well cooked and reasonable prices. Will return
Placeholder image
Bill Stanko
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-07-19
Very good. Small place. Had to special which was a whole fish and it was a whole fish.
Placeholder image
Jane Sohn
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-07-27
Super cute place, great food
Placeholder image
Artëm Кazantsev
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-09-30
I bought a Groupon and didn't expect too much. I was surprised by the quality of their service, the food and ambiance. This place is relatively new and they are still establishing themselves in the neighborhood, it is cozy, charming and welcoming. We had oysters- excellent!, I had meetballs - they were not overcooked and were delicious. Wine selection is decent. The place is not cheap - in all senses of the word.
Placeholder image
Seth C
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-10-09
Took my family here for a nice birthday meal on our visit to the city. Great, cozy decor, excellent drinks, solid service, and nice menu at a relatively affordable price. We loved it!
Placeholder image
Sean Buckley
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-11-01
Excellent staff, fast service, great atmosphere. It’s been a while since I felt really welcome at a restaurant - felt more like a local family restaurant than NYC. Pierogies (sp?) were amazing, meatballs were just OK
Placeholder image
Wojtek Mąkosa
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-11-11
Love this place. Interior is great, nice and friendly staff. We had shrimp king salad and surf burger both perfect. Great place for brunch amazing service and delicious eggs Scandinavia.
Placeholder image
Crissi Beth
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-12-05
I just went to the bar here, so my review can only speak to that. The bartenders were very friendly and pretty attentive. I enjoyed the regulars who were at the bar. I feel like this bar manages to be pretty approachable yet keep an upscale feel. They have nice happy hour specials, I had a $6 margarita. The bathroom door is really fun because it is a bookcase that is mounted on a door. I'd be happy to stop back here for a drink anytime.
Placeholder image
Jason Diaz
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-12-01
Gotta say that the food, service, atmosphere and the bartender were all amazingly superb! What a great time with a party of five. They accommodated every want/need. The octopus and the scallops stood out as better than almost any place I've ever been to. The nautical decor was just right. Not over the top or cheesy. Love this place and can't wait to go back.
Placeholder image
Vladimir Chalyshev
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-12-30
Very friendly personnel and fast service. The food quality is also on the top level. Had a grilled Scottish salmon which was delicious! The bonus points are for the decor inside the restaurants. Would definitely come back on my next visit to NYC.
Placeholder image
Maria Cole
Rating results
Rating scope
2019-01-18
Nice spot for date night or small group. Seafood-heavy menu. Octopus app was very good, incredibly tender. Fresh creamy burrata. Nice salmon entree. Friendly and attentive service.
Placeholder image
Leticia
Rating results
Rating scope
2019-02-24
Beautiful space and great seafood. I got a seafood salad and it was mind blowing. Bonus: we went there for brunch and it was quiet and not hectic which is rare for more traditional brunch spots in nyc
Placeholder image
Ashley Ljungbäck
Rating results
Rating scope
2019-03-17
The fish came with no sides. Not a big deal but would have liked for it to be called out. The food was delicious and had a cozy atmosphere.
Placeholder image
Elizabeth Tramantano
Rating results
Rating scope
2019-04-11
Food and service were outstanding! Everything was fresh and the recommendations from our waiter were on point. Can’t wait to go back and try more of the menu!
Placeholder image
Krumrie's Leg
Rating results
Rating scope
2019-04-24
Great find by accident! I happened to walk by and see their daily happy hour specials. $1.25 oysters & $5 Heineken! I couldn't resist! The oysters were super fresh & some of the best I've ever had! The staff was super friendly. They had nice prices & the atmosphere was very welcoming. I would go far out of my way to go back there!
Placeholder image
Peter Gegovic
Rating results
Rating scope
2019-04-27
Incredible service and delicious food... bartender Jason was remarkable and gave us top notch service and drinks.. I highly recommend this place
Placeholder image
Dorline B
Rating results
Rating scope
2019-05-03
Great quality of oysters. Place has a nice ambience. Want to go back because I had mouth surgery and cdn't eat or try the drinks. Food smelled delicious
Placeholder image
Steven Berger
Rating results
Rating scope
2019-06-28
Nice local place. Freshest clams on the half shell. Wonderful grilled octopus and tuna tartare. Fish fresh and simple. Service attentive and helpful. Go here!
Placeholder image
Ashley Mitchell
Rating results
Rating scope
2019-07-24
Amazing food and service. I wouldn't order the lobster roll again, but I would definitely order the tuna on crack and octopus again. The ambiance and attentive staff are superb. I will definitely be back.
Placeholder image
Josh Berger
Rating results
Rating scope
2019-08-02
The food here is pretty good. Went in as I had heard the burger was good. The place looked as though it was straight out of Hawaii. It honestly was really nice. The burger itself was not bad. The price is really the only downside. There also isn't much of a local craft beer selection. Come here if you're looking for great seafood.
Placeholder image
Alex Young
Rating results
Rating scope
2019-08-10
First time... It's clear Shadmpor has a loyal following. Service, specials, solid menu part of reason why.
Placeholder image
Laurie Quinn
Rating results
Rating scope
2019-09-26
Excellent food and great service friendly staff. Really nice Hamptons theme
Placeholder image
Gracie Joseph
Rating results
Rating scope
2019-10-12
We felt really rushed after we finished eating and there were PLENTY of empty tables available. Very impolite. I will not be rushing to go back anytime soon!
Placeholder image
ghilles ainouche
Rating results
Rating scope
2019-11-23
This place is amazing, they probably serve the best octopus in the city, everything is just perfect from the delicious well presented dishes to the service, I love going there the servers are very friendly and professional I always enjoy discussing science with Ali my favorite waiter, Jack the owner always make sure that we are having a great time, like I said great not good but unforgettable experience.
Placeholder image
Ehud Kaminer
Rating results
Rating scope
2019-11-30
A very nice place to sit and chill, the food is good, but the staff was excellent, so all in all a good place
Placeholder image
Bill O'Brien
Rating results
Rating scope
2019-12-09
I live in the neighborhood and this is my go to seafood restaurant It’s excellent food, wonderful atmosphere and friendly service.
Placeholder image
Ross Freiman
Rating results
Rating scope
2019-12-06
Food is good but they need to work on quality / prep. Had numerous bones left in my fish and almost choked on one.
Placeholder image
Shuo Zhang
Rating results
Rating scope
2019-12-20
Easy going manager. Fresh seafood. I really like the salmon.
Placeholder image
Ivan Collins
Rating results
Rating scope
2019-12-28
We finally made it into the Shadmoor and very glad we did. The restaurant offers a smaller footprint with maybe 15-20 tables and a cozy bar. Staff were very friendly, a manager checked in on us a few times and answered my prying questions about making aioli. Ambiance was nice but not over the top in a stuffy way of any sort. We ordered a fried calamari that was exceptional. Just a light dose of batter to give it a delicate crunch without drowning out the flavor of the calamari. They make a great basil pesto like aioli to go with it. I wouldn't mind taking a jar of that home. I also had the grilled baby octopus that was lights out. Very colorful dish, grilled to perfection, that melted in your mouth. My girlfriend had the french onion soup which comes in the typical cute bowl and was golden brown. Seemed a little risky to order a french item at a seafood place, but it was right on target. I don't think these guys let anything escape the kitchen less than perfect. I also tried a craft Moscow mule that seemed to have the right balance of ginger and kapow. My only regret is that we dined during lunch. I want to try this menu for dinner next.
Placeholder image
Lady Ace
Rating results
Rating scope
2020-01-10
We came here for an after-dinner snack and to watch the game. The beautifully decorated restaurant had a homey and quaint feel. I loved the beautiful decoration and while, the restaurant was on the small in size, they utilized the space beautifully. Since we weren't having a full dinner, we decided to sit at the bar. Our bartender, Jason, was very friendly and nice. I ordered the Iron Skillet Shrimp for $18. I was surprised by how small the portion size was. I felt like 3 shrimp for $18 was pretty steep. I thought the shrimp and the chickpeas were different and tasty. I wasn't fond of the reddish-purple sauce on the plate. The menu said it was roasted peppers but, it reminded me of beets. I might come back again if I am in the neighborhood but, I will stick to the $30 prix fixe dinner or the happy hour special.
Placeholder image
R P
Rating results
Rating scope
2020-01-15
Food is great and they have an awesome happy hour! Elio is the most patient and kind waiter. I appreciate his service which is rare in NYC. Love him!
Placeholder image
Kristin Haran
Rating results
Rating scope
2020-01-13
Good brunch food and menu but no dairy free milk!
Placeholder image
Geoff D
Rating results
Rating scope
2020-02-06
Great atmosphere, great service and great food! Food is delicious but not pretentious.
Placeholder image
JK Hegarty
Rating results
Rating scope
2020-02-21
GREAT FOOD! Service was friendly & timely. I will return with more friends.
Placeholder image
Mark Dimont
Rating results
Rating scope
2020-02-21
Great branzino and pleasant environment in midtown east. Felt cozy and the staff were warm. Cool secret bathroom doors.
Placeholder image
Daniel Correa
Rating results
Rating scope
2020-03-11
Well prepared and presented food in a comfortable setting. An excellent atmosphere. The service is good with attentive but not over bearing staff. A bit pricy nut I would recommend it.
Placeholder image
cesar yazbeck
Rating results
Rating scope
2020-03-13
Great lucky find, we stumbled on this restaurant by luck. The mood is very nice, it’s a very nice and warm set-up. The food was great across the board. One hiccup, we ordered the two course lunch menu offer but were charged for full cost of 4 full plates because the waiter “misunderstood” what we meant by lunch menu despite them having it clearly written on a chalkboard.
Placeholder image
Rufus Petty
Rating results
Rating scope
2020-03-22
This spot is great and roomy, the menu was enchanting and the rates were very inexpensive. quickly, productive service and very personal staff. Recommended.
Placeholder image
Dimitrios D
Rating results
Rating scope
2019-04-26
The Shadmoor is a delicious American seafood restaurant. Service was friendly and efficient, and the food was great. The ambiance is nautically themed and pleasant. To begin, the raw oysters were good (though not the best shucked ever), and the octopus appetizer was fancifully presented and very tasty. However my main course, the swordfish steak, was amazing and definitely the star of the show. Juicy and delicious, topped with capers in a butter lemon sauce. The regular steak was surprisingly good, too, especially for a seafood place- better than a steak au poivre that I had a French restaurant not long ago. Highly recommended!
Placeholder image
Daniel Correa
Rating results
Rating scope
2020-06-26
Well prepared and presented food in a comfortable setting. An excellent atmosphere. The service is good with attentive but not over bearing staff. A bit pricy but I would recommend it.
Placeholder image
Koltyn Hadrian
Rating results
Rating scope
2020-07-15
Last week was the first time we visited this restaurant. But It is obviously not the last time. We enjoyed the evening a lot with the generous service, with the magnificent meal and wine and with the decent cost. We will no doubt go back there soon.
Placeholder image
Terrel Sykes
Rating results
Rating scope
2020-07-19
The service and the food was great. Their outdoor seating and adherence to social distancing made this experience very comfortable.
Placeholder image
Marina Dmitrieva
Rating results
Rating scope
2020-08-09
I’ve got a very nice service and I was put at the table immediately Oysters were delicious but I took only half dozen because of the price (18$ for 6 pieces) Not sure if they have happy hours now Also ordered octopus and enjoyed it Just one thing I was unhappy about it’s a waiting time about 25min to get oysters and 15min after to get octopus Total check was 40$ Ok for Manhattan’s restaurant with good atmosphere I didn’t take any drinks but food was definitely good and no need to lower rating for the waiting time
Placeholder image
Ameya Bhakay
Rating results
Rating scope
2020-08-08
Went here on a Saturday evening at around 5:30 pm: a pretty good time to go since you can even get a table with walk-in. We however, made a reservation for 5:30. They have a pretty good outdoor seating space on a nice tree-lined street and we were seated at a good table. We got a bottle of Pinot Grigio ($43) and a bottle of Rose ($47) which were served in a nice ice-cold bucket. For sides, we got the Grilled Veggies ($7) with Trio Dips which comes with toasted pita ($10) and Caramelized Brussels Sprouts ($7). The sprouts were okay I felt, contrary to all other reviews that raved about them. For mains, we got Steamed Mussels ($17) and wanted it with the coconut curry sauce, which unfortunately wasn't available and got it with the tomato basil sauce instead. People who ate it weren't that impressed with the mussels. The Grilled Salmon ($28) on the other hand was thoroughly enjoyed and disappeared within a few mins after it was served. I got the Beet Salad ($15) which was excellent - highly recommended for vegetarians! Service was excellent and food arrived within 20-mins of placing our order. Will definitely recommend to friends and family.
Placeholder image
Clay Davis
Rating results
Rating scope
2020-08-14
It’s very tough to run a restaurant now. But this place does pretty well. My preference is to come earlier before it gets too crowded. But even at 6pm, most tables are booked.
Placeholder image
Dirk
Rating results
Rating scope
2020-08-22
Nice Irish pub, sitting outside in a quiet street. Perfect fish’n chips. Good draft beers.
Placeholder image
Jacob Landsman
Rating results
Rating scope
2020-09-05
The food and service was solid but my girlfriend ordered the avocado toast which was pathetically small for how expensive it was. 16 dollars for a tiny piece of bread with some avocado and eggs is ridiculous. Do not order the avocado toast here.
Placeholder image
Sarah
Rating results
Rating scope
2020-09-16
Amazing seafood salad for lunch. Great cocktails. Cute outdoor dining space
Placeholder image
Cathie Staiano
Rating results
Rating scope
2020-09-06
Just Loved it! Doggies Allowed!
Placeholder image
Brett Cline
Rating results
Rating scope
2020-09-07
Nice outdoor seating area, service was alright.
Placeholder image
Lady Ace
Rating results
Rating scope
2020-01-10
We came here for an after-dinner snack and to watch the game. The beautifully decorated restaurant had a homey and quaint feel. I loved the beautiful decoration and while, the restaurant was on the small in size, they utilized the space beautifully. Since we weren't having a full dinner, we decided to sit at the bar. Our bartender, Jason, was very friendly and nice. I ordered the Iron Skillet Shrimp for $18. I was surprised by how small the portion size was. I felt like 3 shrimp for $18 was pretty steep. I thought the shrimp and the chickpeas were different and tasty. I wasn't fond of the reddish-purple sauce on the plate. The menu said it was roasted peppers but, it reminded me of beets. I might come back again if I am in the neighborhood but, I will stick to the $30 prix fixe dinner or the happy hour special.
Placeholder image
Marina Dmitrieva
Rating results
Rating scope
2020-08-09
I’ve got a very nice service and I was put at the table immediately Oysters were delicious but I took only half dozen because of the price (18$ for 6 pieces) Not sure if they have happy hours now Also ordered octopus and enjoyed it Just one thing I was unhappy about it’s a waiting time about 25min to get oysters and 15min after to get octopus Total check was 40$ Ok for Manhattan’s restaurant with good atmosphere I didn’t take any drinks but food was definitely good and no need to lower rating for the waiting time
Placeholder image
Eli Lyakhovich
Rating results
Rating scope
2020-12-19
Been here twice so far with my wife. The food is absolutely delicious! We tried 9 dishes so far and 8 of them were AMAZING! Everything is super fresh and portioned perfectly for up to 4 in my opinion. We usually order 4 appetizers for the both of us instead of a main and its more than enough. The service is efficient and the staff is friendly. Highly recommend!
Placeholder image
Hannah Rose Schonwald
Rating results
Rating scope
2020-12-29
Amazing food and delicious cocktails. Great service and atmosphere. Perfect restaurant for celebrating or for a nice brunch.
Placeholder image
Alice S
Rating results
Rating scope
2021-01-10
Felt very safe, the brunch food was great, and it was warm enough even in January with the outdoor heaters.
Placeholder image
nasyaw smalley
Rating results
Rating scope
2021-01-11
The decor was better than the dining. If not for the ambience I would've give 3 stars.
Placeholder image
Nasir Lawson
Rating results
Rating scope
2021-01-19
This spot sure knows how to take care of their customers. Always with a very welcoming mindset. The food is affordably priced, constantly yummy and neat.
Placeholder image
Leslie Moore
Rating results
Rating scope
2021-02-15
Went to this restaurant for valentines Day , service was excellent and food was amazing. Restaurant seemed cozy and romantic. I highly recommend :)
Placeholder image
Mariel Synan
Rating results
Rating scope
2021-04-26
Excellent happy hour deals on food and drinks - and generous wine pours! Loved the tuna on crack
Placeholder image
Amy Roberts
Rating results
Rating scope
2021-05-12
Cocktails were great but we had a couple oysters that caused us not to finish the rest of our dozen.
Placeholder image
Janice Brooks
Rating results
Rating scope
2021-05-11
The atmosphere is great for conversations. The food is good but comes in small portions at moderate prices.
Placeholder image
Ching Ip
Rating results
Rating scope
2021-05-23
Can't beat the happy hour from 4-6pm. Everything from the happy hour menu was amazing. Will recommend it and will definitely be back for more!
Placeholder image
Victoria
Rating results
Rating scope
2021-07-19
Great restaurant, loved the seafood! Staff was excellent, especially the hostess Kiara
Placeholder image
Paul Rigano
Rating results
Rating scope
2021-07-28
Delightful experience! The staff was very friendly, the food was delicious, and the outdoor space very comfortable. A bit pricey, but hey, it's midtown east. A perfect spot for a nice lunch.
Placeholder image
James Song
Rating results
Rating scope
2021-07-24
Happy hour is nice but the oysters had no flavor. Ordered 24- all of them tasted like they were raised in fresh water. Also no air-conditioning, so if it's a hot day, you're gna be hot. Burger sliders were good.
Placeholder image
Chuck Fogle
Rating results
Rating scope
2021-07-28
Food is excellent, service was slow. Had to ask 3-4 times for water, more bread and even the check. Understand the pandemic is effecting staff but I question if that is the real issue.
Placeholder image
Hannie R.
Rating results
Rating scope
2021-08-01
A lovely place! We sat for a beer, and added the grilled calamari, which was very tasty. The only thing that was annoying, was the service... The waiters were nice, but it took them ages to bring the check, and then to get the payment... But, it was a great evening, with great live music.
Placeholder image
Tyler Smith
Rating results
Rating scope
2021-08-14
My wife and I visited The Shadmoor for dinner on 8/13/21. We were offered indoor and outdoor seating and we choose indoor. They seated us near the back of the restaurant in an intimate corner with a good amount of date lighting (dark but not too dark). We were quickly served waters and ordered cocktails. The drinks were great and I ended up getting three different cocktails during dinner. We ordered a salad, the cast iron shrimp, and two dozen oysters. The food was incredible and the staff worked very hard to provide great service. It was truly a 5-star meal, and as an oyster-lover that no longer lives on the east coast, the oysters were fantastic. Strongly recommend to any locals and tourists that are craving oysters or seafood + cocktails.
Placeholder image
Marilyn Kane
Rating results
Rating scope
2021-09-03
Wonderful oysters and great cocktails. There is a very good outdoor space for a lovely happy hour or dinner visit.
Placeholder image
Nouchie
Rating results
Rating scope
2021-09-12
Three eggs omelette: with tomato's, olives and feta cheese is fantastic. The eggs are cooked perfectly and the addition of ingredients are not overbearing. Five of five stars. Country style sausage: cooked well, however sausage is a bit salty. Overall, four of five stars. Hand cut french fries: well seasoned, not too salty. French fries are cut thin, which is somehow a good thing. Overall, five of five stars. Pinot Grigio: a good year but relatively new and not aged as a good white should be, served chilled as it should be. Overall, four of five stars.
Placeholder image
Jenny Luu
Rating results
Rating scope
2021-09-24
The place has a cute cozy vibe. They served this bread with olive oil with our drinks and it was delicious. The drink I got was okay. It was like a watermelon cocktail; it was a little bit too strong for my liking.
Placeholder image
Christina Jones
Rating results
Rating scope
2021-10-12
I’ve only popped in here during brunch for a drink. I was really in the mood for mussels and they didn’t really have any seafood on their brunch menu. I live close by so I’ll have to come back so that I can actually try the food. It’s a lovely place, super cool bathroom, and is always a popular place.
Placeholder image
Jenny L
Rating results
Rating scope
2021-09-24
The place has a cute cozy vibe. They served this bread with olive oil with our drinks and it was delicious. The drink I got was okay. It was like a watermelon cocktail; it was a little bit too strong for my liking.
Placeholder image
Eugene Shagenov
Rating results
Rating scope
2021-10-22
We all really wanted to like it, but one thing went wrong after another. We asked for everything to come out in the order in which it would be ready. Salads could come out first, since they don’t have to be cooked. We also asked for the kid’s meal to be prioritized. Instead, nothing came out until everything came out. And some of the hot food was like warm, as if it had been waiting somewhere for a while. The kid’s meal came out last. We waited about 50 minutes for any food to come out. Then there were strange things like someone coming over with more coffee, but walking away after refilling only one person’s cup. The food was ok. One of the omelets was a strange pale color as if it consisted mostly of egg whites, though that wasn’t the description on the menu. It didn’t quite taste right either. Zucchini pancakes were not quite what I expected either, I guess a different recipe. Seafood salad was not bad, but had exactly 1 shrimp. Fries were decent, though inconsistent— some were dry and hard, others good. Salmon burger was ok, but would have been better if it were warmer. Eggs Benedict didn’t receive any complaints. Overall, we were disappointed. The saving grace was that the waiter seemed to genuinely care that things went wrong, asked us about it, and got us two desserts on the house to make up for it. That was a nice touch.
Placeholder image
Eddy E.
Rating results
Rating scope
2021-12-21
Delicious oysters and perfect atmosphere. Very kind stuff. Best place to eat and enjoy your time in NYC. Thanks for this experience.
Placeholder image
fernando babilonia
Rating results
Rating scope
2022-02-18
Been having a craving for oysters for the first time in a few years and the hunt was on. Stumbled upon the Shadmoor and tried it out... Loved it had to order more because the oysters were better than I remembered. Service a little slow but the food was worth it!( Only reason not 5)
Placeholder image
Carole Johnson
Rating results
Rating scope
2022-05-15
My 1st review ever! bcuz we had such a delightful dinner here - we had the best waitress ever - Gianni! Absolutely lovely, professional and friendly. And the food and drinks were delicious. It was such an impressive evening. And such a cute restaurant. Great crowd... It was all good. Thank you Shadmoor. We look forward to more!
Placeholder image
Janet Fox
Rating results
Rating scope
2022-06-14
Our lunch was great—everything was excellent. Enjoyed the specialty lemonade cocktail. Loved the crab cake appetizer. The salmon burger and angus brisket were perfect, and the profiteroles were to die for! Great service, highly recommended. We will definitely be back!!
Placeholder image
Ben Vance
Rating results
Rating scope
2022-08-24
Nice and relaxing place to dine particularly the happy hour. Everything on the happy hour menu floats around the $10 mark and are all delicious. Staff is friendly and accommodating. Recommend checking this place out for a relaxing happy hour in a somewhat modern Mediterranean/Pacifica environment.
Placeholder image
Carly Pisarri
Rating results
Rating scope
2022-08-30
This place was a 2.5 at best but I rounded up. The portions were small, the table was small and couldn’t even fit the plate which is something in and of itself, and the service was pretty slow. Maybe it was an off day but the calamari was good and the decor was cute. It’s not enough for me to return though.
Placeholder image
A.B. Brown
Rating results
Rating scope
2022-08-28
Good food. Good prices. Dulal was a great waiter. Wish the kitchen crew would’ve gotten our orders correct the first time. Other than that it wasn’t too bad
Placeholder image
Alexandra Rogers
Rating results
Rating scope
2022-06-05
First time at this lovely neighborhood sports. It feels like a little vacation. We ate outside on a beautiful tree lined block in a covered eating area. The staff was very welcoming and attentive. We really enjoyed our food. I got the zucchini pancakes, reccomended by the waitress Giana. Great pick! My husband had the crab benedict...not a piece left. We followed it up with a delicious apple strudel. We will definitely go back.
Placeholder image
TAYLOR BARTOE
Rating results
Rating scope
2022-05-15
I took my mother and family here on mother’s day. The whole staff was super accommodating- they even let us order off of the dinner menu despite it being a pre fix during brunch hours. We had to order another Grilled octopus appetizer as it was one of the best i’ve ever had. We ordered 4 different appetizers and 6 entrees and everyone was blown away with their dish. From the crabs eggs benedict, swordfish sandwich to the Chicken The Shadmoor has something for everyone. The cocktails are just as delicious. Our server Gigi really made our experience memorable- I will be requesting her from now on!
Placeholder image
Cesar Desouza
Rating results
Rating scope
2022-10-08
We found this place. We were starving. The tables are small and there is no room for food and drinks. Staff very attentive. Overprice place. Appetizers: Watermelon Salad, Half Oysters Raw. For entrees: Angus Steak and Lobster Roll. Three glasses of wine. The food was Fresh, nutritious and tasty. Total paid $180 + 35 tip.
Placeholder image
Amy Chang
Rating results
Rating scope
2022-10-21
A very cozy spot for a romantic date or a nice chat with friends. Servers give the right amount of attention. Shadmoor Smash cocktail is a nice refreshing gin drink and they’re oysters were fresh and flavorful. We did a mix of appetizers to share and it was a perfect meal with our drinks. Will definitely return.
Placeholder image
Amy C
Rating results
Rating scope
2022-10-21
A very cozy spot for a romantic date or a nice chat with friends. Servers give the right amount of attention. Shadmoor Smash cocktail is a nice refreshing gin drink and they’re oysters were fresh and flavorful. We did a mix of appetizers to share and it was a perfect meal with our drinks. Will definitely return.
Load more reviews Show More
Show less reviews Show Less
Thank you Danijel Grabež. You are successfully signed up to Diamond Tables.
Close notification