With Diamond Tables you receive 25% off the check at

Margari Pizza

Classic Italian$10 - $20
1072 2nd Avenue, New York City, NY 10022
Rating results
Rating scope
62 reviews
Make a Reservation

Restaurant Information

Greetings & Welcome to Magari Pizza

When you step inside the door of Magari Pizza for the first time, you will know you’ve found the greatest place in New York City for traditional and authentic Italian cuisine.

Our chefs select only the finest and freshest ingredients on the planet to prepare the fantastic foods we serve. We will provide you with an experience that is a step above our competition; you will leave feeling satiated and happy.

Our eclectic menu offers pages of delicious foods for you. Salads, soups, heros, baked pastas like manicotti, ziti, ravioli, lasagna, eggplant rollatini with spaghetti. Our chicken, veal and seafood dishes are divine. Our pizzas are hand-made and the variety we create is almost endless! We also provide awesome catering service with ½ trays for 10-12 and full tray that serve 20-25.

Diamond Tables

Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat

Reviews

Overall Rating

4.2
Rating results
Rating scope
62 reviews
  • 5 Stars
  • 4 Stars
  • 3 Stars
  • 2 Stars
  • 1 Star
Placeholder image
Ruchik Patel
Rating results
Rating scope
2017-08-01
#bestpizza#bestpasta#bestservice. One should visit at least once.
Placeholder image
Luke Wallace
Rating results
Rating scope
2017-03-17
Excellent italian food, at very reasonable prices. Quality of the bread is great, and the portions of everything are huge. Friendly staff too!
Placeholder image
Michael Engel
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-03-08
Really good chicken frencaise and ministrone soup! Excellent non pizza food for a pizza place!
Placeholder image
Magdalena 0
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-06-25
Like NYC pizza should be. Thin, crispy crust, melty cheese and chewy–tender bread with an amazing texture. Sauce has a touch of sweetness. My custom-made veggie slice was perfect. The chicken–avocado salad is also worthwhile : freshly grilled real chicken breast over a mix of vegetables and crisp lettuce, served with 3 garlic knots. Kind service, clean pizzeria that turns full-service restaurant in the evenings... or when you order foods like that.
Placeholder image
Ruben Rivera
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-06-25
Excellent spot for a great meal reasonably priced. The chicken salad lunch special is excellent.
Placeholder image
Amin Rabinia
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-08-18
Good experience. Especially brick oven ones
Placeholder image
Sandy Chen
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-10-01
Amazing pizza! The sausage slice was absolutely tasty!
Placeholder image
Casey Mattos
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-10-25
Some of the best pizza I've had in the city, although I was only there for a week. I'm sure there's other great places, and perhaps even better ones, but you can't argue with what's right in front of you. Great atmosphere, great food, reasonably priced.
Placeholder image
Chris M
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-11-08
Outta towner, but have visited many times the pizza (regardless of type) is always good.
Placeholder image
Kevin Rosen
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-11-19
Absolutely one of the best cheese pizzas in NYC ! Dinner Salad and pasta dishes are also fantastic.
Placeholder image
Mg 0
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-06-25
Like NYC pizza should be. Thin, crispy crust, melty cheese and chewy–tender bread with an amazing texture. Sauce has a touch of sweetness. My custom-made veggie slice was perfect. The chicken–avocado salad is also worthwhile : freshly grilled real chicken breast over a mix of vegetables and crisp lettuce, served with 3 garlic knots. Kind service, clean pizzeria that turns full-service restaurant in the evenings... or when you order foods like that.
Placeholder image
Nick R.
Rating results
Rating scope
2018-12-14
Nice establishment. Quaint but good food and decent prices. Pizza was ok, would def recom individual pie vs by the slice. Got a side of meatballs (2) bout the size of a tennis ball, $8. Good meatballs but not a $4 meatball, to my standards. Wings were delish! A touch of spice but well crispy. Probably best item we had, they went quick!
Placeholder image
Emerson Erazo
Rating results
Rating scope
2019-02-15
I just had the perfect Valentines date. The restaurant was perfect. Riches and Dencys took care of us like VIP customers, the prices are very good and happy hour all night, the sea food was delicious. I will recommend Pecorino wine bottle. Just perfect and there is only one way to find out
Placeholder image
Kalpesh Patel
Rating results
Rating scope
2019-03-07
Great place great food great quality
Placeholder image
Penny Errico-Nagar
Rating results
Rating scope
2019-03-08
Great staff, food, prices
Placeholder image
Rhonda Plaza
Rating results
Rating scope
2019-03-21
Food is good and the service is great.
Placeholder image
R P
Rating results
Rating scope
2019-03-21
Food is good and the service is great.
Placeholder image
Shani Finbar
Rating results
Rating scope
2019-05-13
Good food. Good happy hour specials.
Placeholder image
Claire Andrews
Rating results
Rating scope
2019-06-19
Really liked this place we discovered on our way to the Roosevelt tramway the staff were very pleasant and accommodating food was tasty and fresh we had the lunch special a large slice of pizza, a salad and soda we chose the cheese pizza and Cesar salad we added chicken to the salad good value for money
Placeholder image
Patrick Shevlin
Rating results
Rating scope
2019-07-24
Good slice if you're just looking for a quick bite on lunch. No AC or fans. Friendly and quick service though.
Placeholder image
Hamilton Colwell
Rating results
Rating scope
2019-07-31
We were the only people seated on a Tuesday night, but with this quality food and very friendly and professional staff, we’ll absolutely go back.
Placeholder image
Marley Montoya
Rating results
Rating scope
2019-08-13
The food is constantly well prepared and delicious, staff members provides excellent customer service. I love how clean it is and mood. Would recommend to others.
Placeholder image
Christine Rostvold
Rating results
Rating scope
2019-08-22
Good food - minestrone made from scratch, broad menu and really nice service. A pleasant surprise.
Placeholder image
Jeff Wallace
Rating results
Rating scope
2019-08-21
Pretty great. Good pizza, good service. Fairly expensive drinks (any hint other than water)
Placeholder image
Tim Dixon
Rating results
Rating scope
2019-09-22
Had the lunch special, decent food for a decent price.
Placeholder image
Jim Brown
Rating results
Rating scope
2019-11-03
Great tasting pizza, clean restaurant, and friendly service.
Placeholder image
Daina Gigliotti - Dozzi
Rating results
Rating scope
2020-05-25
Great pizza! I got delivery and it arrived crazy fast & piping hot. Will definitely order from them again
Placeholder image
Mikki Coronado
Rating results
Rating scope
2020-03-10
Wings were delicious!! Great service! Nice, clean restaurant
Placeholder image
Alan Adler
Rating results
Rating scope
2020-03-10
Lived all over the city for 47 years and this is by far the best Italian Food I’ve eaten in Manhattan! The quality, the quantity + presentation and taste is way past primo! These are the reviews you save for family! Believe me, this is one restaurant you will return to over and over! Friendly guys too!
Placeholder image
SarraiGlam
Rating results
Rating scope
2020-03-02
First time walking in today. I loveeed it . The cheese and crust perfectly cooked. Can’t have enough .
Placeholder image
Paul Young
Rating results
Rating scope
2020-08-01
Placeholder image
Harry Griffin
Rating results
Rating scope
2020-09-19
2 very strong slices
Placeholder image
Daina Gigliotti - Dozzi
Rating results
Rating scope
2020-05-25
Great pizza! I got delivery and it arrived crazy fast & piping hot. Will definitely order from them again
Placeholder image
SarraiGlam (Sarraiglam)
Rating results
Rating scope
2020-03-02
First time walking in today. I loveeed it . The cheese and crust perfectly cooked. Can’t have enough .
Placeholder image
Catherine Wilson
Rating results
Rating scope
2020-11-08
We had delivery from Margari Pizza EVERY DAY we were in New York City (3 days!). The service was always fast and courteous, the helpings were sizable and the quality and flavor on point. WOULD HIGHLY RECOMMEND.
Placeholder image
Jonathan Zisser
Rating results
Rating scope
2021-01-03
Tasty pizza and friendly staff! If I'm passing through I'd stop in for a slice again!
Placeholder image
Ali Essa
Rating results
Rating scope
2021-02-18
Placeholder image
Mohamed Halawa
Rating results
Rating scope
2021-03-21
I absolutely love this place. Very delicious pizza
Placeholder image
Nadim Elnokrashy
Rating results
Rating scope
2021-03-21
Great pizza with the best staff. Fast delivery. For sure my favorite pizza place ♥️.
Placeholder image
saif kaemr2
Rating results
Rating scope
2021-03-21
Favorite pizza ever great staff and definitely recommend their kitchen dishes
Placeholder image
Sammer Elnokrashy
Rating results
Rating scope
2021-03-21
The pizza was really good the cheese on the pizza tasted so good perfect crust . 5 star pizza.
Placeholder image
jaben lake
Rating results
Rating scope
2021-04-08
I cannot get enough of margari! I order from there 5 days a week after work and the food is always so good! On top of that the customer service is very good and they treat you kindly (:
Placeholder image
April Lawrence
Rating results
Rating scope
2021-04-09
The food was really good!!! I enjoyed the chicken piccata and yummy carrot cake.
Placeholder image
hend Y
Rating results
Rating scope
2021-05-04
It’s my number one spot to go to whenever I go to the city. Their pizza is definitely delicious and not oily at all. I totally recommend it.
Placeholder image
Ahmed Elkhoudari
Rating results
Rating scope
2021-05-01
Place has Delicious pizza! Their Crust is so delicious ! Staff Very Nice! Highly Recommended and I will definitely be back.
Placeholder image
Daina Gigliotti - Dozzi
Rating results
Rating scope
2021-06-16
Great pizza! I got delivery and it arrived crazy fast & piping hot. Will definitely order from them again Edit: every time I order from them after that first time the pizza has been mushy
Placeholder image
Brittany McGlamery
Rating results
Rating scope
2021-07-20
Authentic NY Pizza. Crust was perfectly crispy. Great selection and fast service. So good we went back for a 2nd slice.
Placeholder image
Anusheel Pareek
Rating results
Rating scope
2021-08-10
One bit in, and I felt like clicking a photo to remember it. Lovely.
Placeholder image
Maya Davis
Rating results
Rating scope
2021-10-19
Delicious Pizza and nice staff!! The eggplant pizza is sooooooo good. Some of the pizzas have like shaved parmesan on top and it's amazing
Placeholder image
Linh Tran
Rating results
Rating scope
2021-11-14
The staff members are very nice and pleasant. Came to pick up too good to go and was allow to use restroom and pick up a little earlier.
Placeholder image
Ramey Aly
Rating results
Rating scope
2021-12-02
Yoooo one of the best crispy tasty yummy pizza! A1 deff coming back again and again. Buffalo chicken is my favorite. Didn’t even know that existed. And Yoo let me not forget, garlic knots with cheese what! Man oh man.
Placeholder image
pilar silva
Rating results
Rating scope
2021-12-22
Great pizza, fantastic customer service, delivers on time.
Placeholder image
kathleen walton
Rating results
Rating scope
2022-02-26
Outstanding!!! I just went there for lunch with a friend. The food is exceptional, fantastic! The staff is so very kind, friendly. Great value as well and a great menu. Best sauce. I will be back many times.
Placeholder image
Elene Peters
Rating results
Rating scope
2022-03-24
Best garlic knots in Manhattan. Staff is friendly and the food is good.
Placeholder image
Deborah Day
Rating results
Rating scope
2022-04-05
The pizza is very good; thin and crispy crust with a wide variety of toppings. Homemade soups, salads, pasta and more also available.
Placeholder image
Dan Ferrara
Rating results
Rating scope
2022-04-04
Chicken rolls were really good! They were bogo on Uber eats so I loaded up. They’re on the smaller side but can’t complain when they’re basically 2/$9
Placeholder image
Oliver Metcalfe
Rating results
Rating scope
2022-05-01
One of the only places open late in this part of town and the pizza was delicious! Very much recommended
Placeholder image
Maria
Rating results
Rating scope
2022-06-04
The eggplant pizza!!! Wow!! Thank you! Sooo good. The tomato sauce... Very nice person working there
Placeholder image
Arnold Cabasso
Rating results
Rating scope
2022-06-12
Very happy that Margari was able to quickly accommodate a party of 10 for my birthday. Everyone loved the pizza and sautéed spinach.
Placeholder image
Gabriel Herrera
Rating results
Rating scope
2022-07-30
Great experience with New York pizza! Variety of flavors and options! Overall 10/10
Placeholder image
Mandy Johnson
Rating results
Rating scope
2022-09-29
My server was beyond delightful and the food was spectacular. The eggplant slice was marvelous how ever the veg pizza wasn’t exactly fresh. All together yens have earned four stars and I’d like to request that the server receives a raise.
Placeholder image
David F
Rating results
Rating scope
2022-10-04
Not much to say here, but got a good Chicken Vodka slice here the other night for $5. It's like most other decent pizza joints, where you gotta hit it just right for a fresh slice, but when you do, its good. This flavor was pretty tasty. Quick and easy.
Load more reviews Show More
Show less reviews Show Less
Thank you Danijel Grabež. You are successfully signed up to Diamond Tables.
Close notification